I've been taking ice dance lessons for about a year and half. One would think I'd be better at it by now. Instead, I'm like the annoying eight year old kid in the apartment directly over yours who practices his trumpet each afternoon at precisely those times when you're trying to nap. Every day that brat runs through the scales and hacks his way soullessly through the same handful of simple tunes but he just doesn't seem to be improving. On the rare good days when you're sober and he's at his best, you listen and decide that yeah, OK, his playing is technically proficient--but it lacks emotion.
And that's where I am with ice dance. After a year and a half of work, like the kid upstairs who knows the notes and timing requirements of the different pieces of his limited repertoire, I know the steps of the three preliminary dances and have a notion of their required timings and where the patterns must be on the ice. On good days I can even execute the steps in such a way that my coach can watch and (a). realize that I'm skating a pattern dance and (b). not have to squint too hard when attempting to guess which one. But something is lacking. That something is emotion or essence or perhaps the best word is expression.
What is dance expression? Trust me, if I knew the answer this post would be entirely different. For one thing, I'd be all braggy about how great my execution was and probably I'd be salivating over the prospect of conquering more complex dances. Sadly, this is not so. I'm just a slow learning clod hopper from the country without much musicality.
Now before I totally paint myself in a corner, I'm not totally clueless. Even I grasp the fundamental differences between a Waltz, a Tango, and the Blues. The Tango demands crisp movement with "attitude" while the Blues is "swingy" with big easy curves, smooth as molasses. The Waltz is slower than the Tango or Blues and requires a more elegant and refined approach. The question is, how does one incorporate these differences into skating elements? A progressive is a progressive regardless of whether it's done during a Waltz, a Tango or a Blues dance. How does one shift gears to make a swing roll a Waltz swing roll rather than a Blues swing roll? I don't have an answer today but at least it's dawned on me that I should be thinking about it. Hopefully I'll figure some of this out before I'm too old to dance!
Watching Guillaume Cizeron is very helpful to figure out what expression in ice dance means;-) Also helpful....I took lessons with an experienced dance/figure skating teacher who first coached us in the dance studio and afterwards directly on ice! But it takes time.......and good luck. Another method is to look at a video of lesson now andagain although one looks like crap ;)ReplyDelete
Another personal remark to the standard ice dance music used that is totally IMHO: I find it hard to give any expression to those boring tunes. It is much easier to find a personal expression to a tune I love and is decent!ReplyDelete
Your illustration is of Pakhomova and Gorshkov I think. They skated back in the day when the ballroom ethos of ice dance was supreme. Why not look up some of their videos?ReplyDelete
Ding,Ding,Ding! Yep: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=YALmp4pIawIReplyDelete
I'll never skate anywhere near their level! (Just ain't enough years left on my odometer!)
Ok...I think a video of YOUR ice dancing is in order!! Let's see it! I will be impressed no matter what, I look like an awkward baby deer just trying to skate a slow lap around a rink.ReplyDelete
Emotion and expression are so difficult in ice dancing (unless it's me grimacing after a bad three turn...). I've been told that it really comes from the articulation and rhythm of your ankle and knee bend. But I remember doing a silver tango pattern for a musician/skater friend who did not dance and couldn't hear the music on our ice pods, and then asking her what she thought we were doing. She guessed a waltz! Ack!ReplyDelete
@Johanna Kracke: No videos just yet. Way back when I briefly had a skating partner, our coach made a short video of us attempting to skate the Dutch Waltz. After seeing it my partner promptly abandoned me and took up horse back riding...ReplyDelete
@Joskates: "Grimacing after a bad (fill in the blank)". I've got that bit of "expression well covered! My grimacing generally occurs when I'm "in partner" with my coach and I have a brain freeze midway through a dance and momentarily forget what step(s) comes next! It doesn't help when I remind myself that at my level the dances rarely have more than 14 steps. But, "I've got to admit it's getting better, a little better all the time." (now you'll have that song stuck in your head for the rest of the day!)
Can't get much worse!Delete
Oh, it can always get worse--something to look forward to!Delete